Our experiences in Davangere during the baseline survey

By Lokesh Gujarappa, Manager – Projects, Public Affairs Foundation

Never in my working life of 14 years did I imagine that I would be barging into so many rural households to inspect toilets in the span of 2 months. The credit for this goes primarily to Arghyam!

Scoping for the Survey 

As a first step towards the quantitative assessment of the demand generation campaign in Davangere district, Karnataka, Ravishankar Rao, Sita Sekhar and I carried out a scoping exercise from 21st to 23rd August 2013. This involved visiting Davangere district, collecting background data from the Zilla Panchayat office, gaining an understanding of how the Nirmal Bharat Abhiyan (NBA) works on the ground through discussions with officials at all levels as well as through Focused Group Discussions (FGDs) with villagers.

The visit to Anaji and Anaburu villages in Davangere Taluka, where the scoping was done, began with an FGD with Gram Panchayat (GP) officials. We then started out on a transect walk to observe the status of toilets in the village as well as to conduct FGDs with men and women separately. While Sita did the FGDs with women, Ravi and I spoke to the men. It was found that while men were generally unwilling to build toilets, they sometimes didn’t even feel the need for them; women on the other hand, were unanimous in extolling the virtues of having a toilet in their homes!

Image

GP officials pondering on answers to our questions

Image

Women share their concerns on toilets in the FGDs with Sita

Image

Men talk about what they think toilets are useful for with Ravi and myself

Image

GP officials show off one swanky toilet built under the Nirmal Bharat Abhiyan

Image

Pit stop at a sub-centre: the Auxilliary Nurse and Midwife (ANM) and Health Inspector with Ravi and Sita

Image

Private parking for a cycle!

Sampling Design

In consultation with Arghyam, the sampling was done in such a way that all six talukas were covered and the sample was reflective of the population of Davangere based on many indicators. Proportionate samples were selected from each taluka to make the sample representative – 800 households from 25 GPs selected in the intervention area and 500 from the 20 GPs selected in the non intervention area.

Pilot of questionnaire in Kaidale and Kyatanahalli

After the scoping and discussions with Arghyam on their requirements, the questionnaire for the baseline survey was designed. This questionnaire was piloted in Kaidale (Kaidale GP) and Kyatanahalli (Huchavvanahalli GP) villages in Davangere Taluka by Sita and me on 9th and 10th of December 2013. The purpose of the pilot was to check for comprehensiveness, length, and flow of the questionnaire.

Training of the Team and conducting the Baseline Survey

A team of 23 able enumerators and 4 supervisors (most of them from Davangere) were trained at the ZP office in Davangere over two days in the month of December by Sita, Tibin Jose and I.

Image

Training session in progress under the watchful eyes of Lokesh, Sita and Tibin

The first day was largely spent going over each question carefully till everyone understood it. Some time was spent in carrying out mock interviews. The mock interviews took the enumerators down memory lane about their own villages and how there were hardly any toilets there!

Half a day was spent in Honnuru in Davangere taluka, where each team member was asked to carry out an interview. Most of the enumerators built a rapport with the respondents by speaking in their own dialect of Kannada. The team was put through a debriefing session in the latter half of the day for them to seek any clarifications they needed and for us to understand how they carried out the task. Another session of mock interviews was held as well.

Image

Dry run – Honnuru Village, Davangere Taluk

On 18th December the smaller teams set off to the different Talukas to start the baseline survey. The survey was carried out between 19th and 31st of December 2013. Lalita, Tibin and I monitored the interviews for quality assurance twice during the survey period.

Image

Data collection in Honnali Taluk during the baseline survey

Image

An enumerator observes a toilet in Honnali Taluk during the baseline survey

Stories from the field

PAF’s youngest team member Tibin came across some interesting situations.

Image

A sign in Kannada reads, “Before prayers toilet, armour for a long life”

“In one of the villages, as we went along with the enumerators, we met a lady near a house and asked her if the house had a toilet. She said it did. At our request she proceeded to give us a tour of the toilet and gave us all details of the family as well. While the enumerator was furiously noting down all details in the questionnaire, and asked her how far she has to go to fetch water for the household, it turned out that she was only a neighbor of that household and not a resident of that house!

In another village, I started taking pictures of a ration shop. some curious bystanders asked me who I was, to which I replied ‘Sowchalaya survey‘. After this, they were very forthcoming in giving information, even posed for some pictures and addressing me as Sir!”

In yet another village we found a strange sight: a toilet with no walls and the seat covered with stones! Unable to contain our curiosity, we asked people about it and they said it used to be a functional toilet and was used as well for a while,  but suddenly the household realized that the toilet faced the temple nearby, decided it was ‘unholy’ to use it, and demolished it promptly!

Image

Unholy mess! Temple nearby leads to destroyed and abandoned toilet

Where we are now

After the survey was completed, every questionnaire was scrutinised by the supervisors and then run through a quality check by the PAF team. The quality cleared questionnaires were then given for data entry. The entered data was checked, cleaned, and then analysed at PAF. The baseline report is now being prepared and we will be sharing the findings with everyone soon.

Advertisements

One thought on “Our experiences in Davangere during the baseline survey

  1. Has PAC or PAF or Rohini NIlekhani considered having a very well kept and clean toilet for women with about at least six cabins with a self contained overhead tank for flushing and a septic tank from which methane could be piped out as kitchen fuel.
    NOTE THERE IS A GREAT RELUCTANCE IN RURAL HOUSEHOLDS TO HAVE A TOILET RIGHT IN FRONT OF THEIR HOUSE.HAVE YOU NOTED THIS SENTIMENT/

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s